To check a mortgage broker is legitimate, you need to confirm three things: that the broker holds an Australian credit licence or is a credit representative on ASIC’s register, that the licensee behind the broker is a member of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), and that it gives you the documents the law requires before and while it helps you borrow. The basic checks are free and take a few minutes. This guide walks through them in order, then lists the signs that should make you pause.
Step 1: look the broker up on ASIC’s register
Moneysmart’s advice is to make sure a broker has a licence to give you credit advice, or is a representative of a licensee, before you meet. It points you to ASIC’s Professional Registers Search, where you choose either Credit Representative or Credit Licensee in the “Select Register” drop-down.
The ASIC register shows whether the broker and its licensee are authorised.
ASIC says you can search by individual or company name, registration or licence number, or ACN or ABN, and filter the results by register, status, type of entity and state. A free search shows the name, the registration or licence number, the address, the start date, the status and any conditions on the registration or licence. ASIC updates the registers once a day and shows a timestamp for the last update. You can run the same search on us: our
Adelaide mortgage broker page shows our credit representative number.
When the result appears, compare it with what the broker has told you:
- the name on the register matches the name on the broker’s card, email and website
- the status is current, not ended
- the address and ABN are the business you expect
- you have read any conditions listed against the licence or registration
ASIC adds that one person or business can have more than one registration, so check you are looking at the right register. A broker who is a credit representative will be linked to a licensee, and the licensee is the business that holds the credit licence.
Step 2: check the business is an AFCA member
If a broker gives you poor advice or charges a fee you did not expect, you can complain to the business, and then to AFCA, which provides free, independent dispute resolution. AFCA says it can only consider complaints about members of its service. AFCA has a Financial Firm Search on its site for checking whether your firm is a member, and it shows the firm’s complaint contact details.
Two points from AFCA’s own wording are worth knowing. If you can’t find your firm in the search, AFCA says it may not be a member. And AFCA’s disclaimer says the search is not its membership register, it displays only organisations AFCA can currently accept complaints against, and membership is not an endorsement of the firm. A result confirms you can complain. It does not say the advice is good.
Step 3: ask which of the four disclosure documents apply
When you check a mortgage broker is legitimate, what they hand you counts as much as what they say. ASIC’s overview of responsible lending disclosure lists the documents a broker, which the law calls a credit assistance provider, must provide. Each one tells you part of what you are signing up for.
Ask which disclosure documents apply before you sign anything.
Document
Preliminary information about the broker. ASIC says it is generally provided before the broker engages in credit activities with you
The estimated cost to you of using the broker’s services, if the broker charges you a fee. You must sign and date it, and the broker must give you a copy, before it provides credit assistance
The costs to you of using the broker’s services, including any indirect remuneration (commission) it may receive. It is given at the same time as the credit assistance
A preliminary or final assessment that the loan is “not unsuitable” for you. ASIC says you can request a free copy within seven years of the date of the quote
Moneysmart adds that lenders generally pay brokers a commission and that brokers must give you information about the commissions they may receive. If a broker can’t explain how it is paid on your loan, or can’t point you to where that is written down, ask again and in writing.
Step 4: ask the questions that test the answer
Paperwork shows the process. Questions show whether the broker is doing it for you. Moneysmart suggests asking:
- Why did you recommend this loan to me, and why is it in my best interests?
- What fees will I have to pay when taking out this loan?
- How do the fees and features of this loan affect how much the loan will cost me?
It also says the broker should present more than one option, explain how each works and what it costs, and show loans from other lenders if you have a preference for your current bank. You do not have to take the first loan offered. If you are not happy with any option, ask for alternatives.
Step 5: know the rule about fees
Most brokers are paid by the lender, so you do not pay them directly. Some also charge you a fee. Moneysmart says that where a broker does, the broker should clearly communicate it and set out the proposed fee in a written quote. You must sign a quote before a broker can provide services and request payment of a fee, and Moneysmart states that a broker is not entitled to request payment of a fee before providing its services.
If a fee is proposed and you are unsure it is fair, Moneysmart suggests asking around or looking online to see what other brokers charge for similar services.
How to check a mortgage broker is legitimate: signs to pause
None of these proves a broker is dishonest. Each is a reason to stop and ask before you hand over documents or money.
- You can’t find the broker or the business on ASIC’s register, or the names don’t match.
- The business does not appear in AFCA’s firm search and the broker can’t explain why.
- You have not been given a credit guide, or the broker plans to charge a fee but you are asked to pay or sign before you have seen a quote.
- You are shown one loan, with no comparison and no reason why it suits you better than others.
- The broker won’t put the recommendation or the commission in writing.
- A fee is requested before the broker has provided any service.
If something goes wrong
Moneysmart’s steps are to complain to your broker’s business in writing first. If the problem is not resolved, contact AFCA, which provides free, independent dispute resolution. AFCA’s number for consumers is 1800 931 678.
Whichever broker you choose, check a mortgage broker is legitimate before you share payslips and bank statements, because those documents hold your identity and your finances.
The broker’s side of the arrangement also matters. If you want to understand where a broker’s income comes from before you ask, read
how mortgage brokers get paid, including the clawback rules and the fee question. You can check Loanity the same way before you book.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if a mortgage broker is legit?
Search the broker on ASIC’s Professional Registers under Credit Representative or Credit Licensee, check the business in AFCA’s Financial Firm Search, and ask for the credit guide, and for a written quote if the broker will charge a fee, before you proceed.
Do mortgage brokers need a licence in Australia?
Moneysmart says to make sure a broker has a licence to give you credit advice or is a representative of a licensee. A credit representative acts under a credit licensee.
What is a credit representative?
It is a person or business authorised by a credit licensee to provide credit services. Credit representatives have their own register on ASIC’s Professional Registers Search.
What can I find on ASIC’s register?
The name, registration or licence number, address, start date, status and any conditions on the registration or licence. ASIC says most of this information is free.
What if my broker is not on the register?
That is a reason to stop. Ask the broker for the licence or registration number and check it yourself before you give them documents or money.
Does AFCA membership mean a broker is good?
No. AFCA says membership is not an endorsement of the firm or its services. It means AFCA can consider complaints about that firm.
Can a broker charge me upfront?
Moneysmart says a broker must give you a written quote that you sign before it provides services and asks for a fee, and that a broker is not entitled to ask for payment of a fee before providing its services.
Can I ask to see why a loan was recommended?
Yes. Moneysmart suggests asking why the loan is in your best interests, and ASIC says you can request a free copy of the written assessment within seven years of the date of the quote.
Talk to us before you decide.
This article is general information only and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Registers, rules and AFCA’s search tool can change, so check each source at the time you use it. It is not legal advice.
Sources