The link between debt consolidation and your credit score runs in two directions. Applying for the new loan leaves a record on your credit report, and the way you manage the new loan and the old accounts afterwards builds the repayment history that lenders read. Neither effect is fixed, and no official source gives a number for how far the debt consolidation credit score effect goes. What you can do is understand each step, so the changes you control work in your favour.
What lenders see on your credit report
Moneysmart says lenders use your credit score, also called a credit rating, to decide whether to lend to you. Your score is calculated from what is in your credit report. It gives examples of what counts: the amount of money you have borrowed, the number of credit applications you have made and whether you pay on time. Depending on the credit reporting body, the score runs from zero to either 1,000 or 1,200, and a higher score means the lender considers you less risky.
A free credit report shows what lenders will see after a consolidation.
Your report is a record of your credit history. It includes your credit products, your repayment history, any defaults and your credit applications. Moneysmart’s credit repair guide spells out how long some of it stays:
- all payments you have made during the last two years on credit cards, loans or bills, whether on time or not
- payments of $150 or more that are overdue by 60 days or more, which stay on your report for five years even after you have paid them off
- all applications for credit cards, store cards, home loans, personal loans and business loans, which stay on your report for five years
There are two main credit reporting bodies in Australia, Experian and Equifax, and they can hold different information. Moneysmart says you have a right to a free copy of your credit report every three months.
The debt consolidation credit score effect, step by step
A consolidation is a handful of events on your file, and each leaves a different mark.
You apply for the consolidation loan
What appears on your credit report: A credit application, which stays for five years
Why it matters: CreditSmart warns that applying to several providers to see what you can get records each application, and other lenders may worry you are borrowing too much
The new loan is approved
What appears on your credit report: A new credit product appears
Why it matters: You now hold a larger loan in place of several smaller debts
The old balances are paid out
What appears on your credit report: Those accounts are repaid, and the cards may be closed
Why it matters: Moneysmart says consolidation works best when you close or reduce old cards and do not take on new debt
You make repayments
What appears on your credit report: Your repayment history shows each month, on time or not
Why it matters: Repayment history covers the last two years, so steady payments build a clean record
A repayment is missed
What appears on your credit report: A late payment appears, and a serious one may become a default
Why it matters: A payment of $150 or more overdue by 60 days or more stays on the report for five years
The application is the part that happens once, and the repayments are the part that happens every month. For most people, the second matters more over time because it builds the record a lender will read the next time you apply.
Why your debt consolidation credit score can look worse in the first few months
Three things tend to coincide, and none of them is a mistake.
The application is recorded straight away. If you applied to more than one provider while comparing, each application is on the report. CreditSmart advises being careful here: when you are in the market to borrow it is tempting to apply to a few credit providers just to see what you can get, but those applications will be recorded and may worry other lenders.
The new loan is usually larger than any one of the debts it replaced. Moneysmart lists the amount you have borrowed as one of the things a score reflects. Moneysmart lists the amount you have borrowed as one factor in your score, and how a lender reads one larger loan compared with several smaller ones depends on the lender.
The new loan has no repayment history yet, so it builds up with each month of on-time repayments. For that reason, a debt consolidation credit score checked in the first weeks may not show where it settles. Our page on
debt consolidation in Adelaide explains how we compare consolidation options for South Australian borrowers.
None of this proves the score will fall. It explains why a dip, where one happens, is not a sign that consolidation failed.
What can actually help your credit file
CreditSmart, a consumer site on credit reporting, gives advice that applies directly:
- Borrow only what you need. Having too much credit may make it harder to get credit for what you really need. If you think you have too much credit open, CreditSmart suggests closing accounts you don’t use.
- Apply deliberately. Choose one lender after comparing terms, and don’t submit applications to see what you can get.
- Pay on time every time. CreditSmart suggests setting up direct debit for at least the minimum payment, because falling behind regularly makes you look worse to credit providers, while forgetting one payment should not affect your credit health too much.
- Check your report for mistakes. Moneysmart says to check that all the loans and debts listed are yours and that details such as your name and date of birth are right. If something is wrong, contact the credit reporting body and ask them to fix it for free.
Closing or reducing old cards stops the debt building up again.
The same Moneysmart consolidation page lists four conditions for a consolidation to help: you pay less overall, the new loan term is not longer than your current debts, you can afford the repayments, and you stop using old credit. The last two conditions protect the credit file as well as your wallet.
Watch out for credit repair companies
Moneysmart says you don’t need to pay a credit repair company to correct errors in your report, because you can do that yourself for free, and that paying one may not improve your score. If you use one, it should be licensed on ASIC’s register.
If you plan to buy or refinance a home soon
Timing matters most when a home loan is the next step. Moneysmart lists who can access your credit report: other credit reporting bodies, credit providers, mortgage insurers, trade insurers, and debt collectors acting for a credit provider. A home loan lender, and a mortgage insurer where one is involved, may be able to see a recent consolidation and the applications around it.
Applications stay on your report for five years, so a consolidation leaves a visible trail for the next lender. That is a point to weigh up, not a reason on its own to avoid consolidating if it lowers your total cost. It is a reason to plan the order: decide whether the home loan or the consolidation comes first, and ask a broker how the lenders you are considering treat recent applications before you lodge either one.
What to do before you apply
- Get your free credit report from both Experian and Equifax and read it, including the list of your credit products.
- Correct any mistakes before you apply.
- Work out the true cost of the new loan against your current debts, including fees, term and rate.
- Choose where to apply, ideally after comparing terms without making formal applications.
- Decide what happens to the old accounts, and don’t reuse the cleared credit.
- Set up automatic repayments on the new loan.
If you would like those steps worked through on your own debts and file, our guide to
what debt consolidation is covers the three common routes and what each costs, and a broker can compare lenders before any application is made.
Frequently asked questions
Does debt consolidation hurt your credit score?
It can lower it at first, because the application is recorded on your report, but there is no official figure for how much. Paying the new loan on time builds your repayment history.
How long does a credit application stay on your credit report?
Moneysmart says applications for credit cards, store cards, home loans, personal loans and business loans stay on your report for five years.
Does a debt consolidation loan show on my credit report?
Yes. It appears as a credit product, with its repayment history, and the application also appears.
Does closing a credit card hurt your score?
Sources are not clear on the size of any effect. CreditSmart suggests closing accounts you don’t use if you have too much credit open, and Moneysmart lists closing or reducing old cards as part of a sound consolidation.
Should I apply to several lenders to compare?
CreditSmart warns that doing so records each application on your report. Compare rates, fees and terms first, then apply once.
How long does it take to rebuild a score after consolidating?
No source gives a time. Repayment history covers the last two years, so steady on-time payments are what build the record lenders read.
What if I miss a repayment on the new loan?
Contact your lender straight away. A payment of $150 or more overdue by 60 days or more stays on your report for five years, even after you have paid it.
Can a credit repair company remove a default for me?
Moneysmart says the only thing a credit reporting body can remove is wrong information, and you can ask for that yourself for free.
Talk to us about consolidating your debts.
This article is general information only and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Credit scoring models differ between credit reporting bodies and change over time, and no source cited here gives a figure for how a particular action changes a score.
Sources